Skip to content

Territory 1 · The meeting record

What CIRO Requires in Meeting Documentation

CIRO's suitability standard and Staff Notice 31-368 show what meeting documentation must demonstrate. The distance from good practice is smaller than you think.

Updated 22 min readSandra Lyne
A mechanical watch movement seen through its open case back, the balance wheel caught mid-swing, one jewel catching the light.

Understanding what CIRO expects from meeting notes means going to the rules, the guidance notes, and the most recent examination findings themselves, not to what the industry assumes or what gets summarized in passing.

CIRO requires meeting documentation that demonstrates a reasonable basis for each suitability determination. Under IDPC Rule 3402(1), advisors must document how they considered five factors: client KYC information, product knowledge (KYP), account impact including concentration and liquidity, cost impact on returns, and reasonable alternatives. Joint CSA/CIRO Staff Notice 31-368 (10 December 2025) (external site, opens in a new tab) reports compliance reviews of 105 registered firms.

Read together, those sources are more specific and less intimidating than their reputation suggests.


Why CIRO documentation requirements feel opaque

The perception that CIRO documentation requirements are unclear is not a lapse of attention. It comes from how the requirements are published.

The documentation expectations are spread across at least eight separate publications: IDPC Rules 3200, 3300, 3400, 3800, and 3900, NI 31-103, Guidance Note GN-3400-21-004, and Staff Notice 31-368. Most are written for compliance officers and securities lawyers, not for the advisor sitting across from a client.

Law firms provide legally precise analysis directed at firms. Trade publications report examination findings. Vendors mention compliance in marketing copy. This page sets out what CIRO requires in practical, advisor-level terms.


What Staff Notice 31-368 revealed

On 10 December 2025, staff of the CSA and CIRO published Staff Notice 31-368 after compliance reviews of 105 registered firms, the second phase of their Client Focused Reforms reviews. The Notice is specific. It lists the issues staff identified and sets out what staff expect.

Four patterns stand out.

1. "Suitable" without basis. Some firms recorded only that an investment was "suitable" without showing the basis for that determination. In its know-your-product guidance, the Notice says that simply stating that securities are "approved" or placing them on an "approved list" without evidence of a reasonable review process is insufficient.

2. "No update" without evidence. The Notice was clear: "A note stating only 'no update' or 'no changes' in the client file or on the KYC form is insufficient without other evidence that a meaningful interaction took place with the client, to avoid solely performing a perfunctory review."

3. Checklists as shortcuts. Among the issues identified was reliance on "superficial tools (e.g., checklists) without supporting documentation of how factors were considered and decisions made."

4. Ranges too broad to be meaningful. The Notice illustrates the point: with net financial assets recorded as a range of $1 million to $5 million, a $400,000 investment "could represent anywhere from 8% to 40% of the client's net financial assets."

CIRO has also said where its examinations are going. CIRO's Compliance Report for 2026 (external site, opens in a new tab) (Administrative Bulletin 26-0034, released 17 February 2026) says of Staff Notice 31-368: "BCC examinations will focus on assessing whether dealers have taken steps to rectify any deficiencies identified in the report that may be applicable to their firm." BCC stands for Business Conduct Compliance.

CIRO's Rule Consolidation Project would replace the IDPC Rules and the Mutual Fund Dealer Rules with one set of CIRO Rules. The proposed rules were published for a 120-day comment period on 12 February 2026 (Rules Bulletin 26-0039 (external site, opens in a new tab)), and comments closed on 12 June 2026. As at 8 October 2026 (external site, opens in a new tab), CIRO estimated that it would publish approval between 1 January and 31 March 2027, and the bulletin proposes an 18-month implementation period. The rule numbers cited on this page are those in force as at 13 November 2026 and will need rechecking when the consolidated rules take effect. The regulatory landscape is not static, but the foundational standard is clear.


The five-factor suitability framework

Under IDPC Rule 3402(1) and NI 31-103 s. 13.3(1), before taking or recommending any investment action for a retail client, registrants must determine, and be able to demonstrate through documentation, that the action satisfies five specific factors:

FactorWhat CIRO expects documented
1. Client KYC informationRisk tolerance, risk capacity, financial circumstances, investment objectives, time horizon, and investment knowledge. Staff Notice 31-368 expects risk tolerance and risk capacity to be assessed separately.
2. Know Your Product (KYP)Understanding of the security's structure, features, risks, and costs. Not just "approved list" membership, but evidence of a reasonable review process.
3. Account impactConcentration and liquidity effects across all accounts held at the firm.
4. Cost impactThe potential and actual impact of costs on the client's return on investment.
5. Reasonable alternativesAlternative actions available through the firm. When recommending a higher-cost product among suitable options, the rationale must be documented.

The standard for all five, in the words of Staff Notice 31-368: documentation "must always be sufficient to demonstrate a reasonable basis for the suitability determination." Not perfection. Not legally bulletproof prose. A reasonable basis.

There is also a proportionality principle. Staff Notice 31-368 acknowledged that documentation completed through centralized or periodic processes "may not need to be repeated each time, provided that the analysis from that process is relied upon when making a recommendation." Firm-level KYP assessments, mandate-level suitability memos, and periodic portfolio reviews can reduce the per-recommendation documentation burden. Where suitability is less clear, more detailed individual records are necessary. The CIRO Compliance Guide's suitability chapter provides detailed examples and a practical memo format for documenting each factor.

The distance from adequate to examination-ready documentation is smaller than most expect.


Why risk tolerance and risk capacity are recorded separately

One of the issues Staff Notice 31-368 identifies is "Risk tolerance and risk capacity factors not considered separately." In the Notice's words: "Some KYC forms combined these factors without distinguishing them clearly, leading to inaccurate risk profiles." The two concepts serve different functions and can lead to different conclusions.

Risk tolerance is psychological. It describes how much portfolio fluctuation a client is willing to accept. A retired teacher who checks her portfolio daily and loses sleep over a 5% decline has low risk tolerance, regardless of her financial position.

Risk capacity is financial. It describes how much loss a client can absorb without materially affecting their lifestyle or goals. That same retired teacher, if she has a fully indexed pension and no debt, may have substantial risk capacity despite her low tolerance for volatility.

When these two assessments are combined into a single field or a blended score, the record does not show how the advisor weighed them. Staff Notice 31-368 sets out that "a client's overall risk profile should reflect the lower of the two" and that "If a registrant determines otherwise, the rationale should be clearly documented." A client with high capacity and low tolerance therefore carries a low risk profile unless the notes show both inputs and a documented rationale for another result.

Staff Notice 31-368 flagged firms where KYC files showed a single "risk profile" rating with no evidence of how tolerance and capacity were assessed individually. The practice is straightforward: document each factor with enough specificity that someone reviewing the file can see the two inputs and understand how the advisor reconciled them.

This is one area where current practice is close to what CIRO expects for most advisors. If you are already having conversations about both how your client feels about risk and what their financial situation can support, what remains is recording those as two distinct observations instead of one.


What the difference looks like on the page

Staff Notice 31-368 lists the issues staff identified and sets out what staff expect. When each pattern and the practice that answers it appear side by side, the distance between them becomes specific and assessable.

Pattern described in Staff Notice 31-368Adequate practice
Recording only that an investment is "suitable" without showing the basisDocumentation that demonstrates consideration of all five suitability factors with enough detail to reconstruct the advisor's reasoning
KYC updates noting "no changes" without evidence of meaningful interactionEvidence that a substantive conversation occurred, even when the KYC information stays the same. In the Notice's words, "retaining supporting evidence is important, even if the result of the interaction was that no changes needed to be made to the KYC information"
Checklists used without supporting documentation of how factors were consideredChecklists supplemented by notes showing how the advisor weighed each factor and reached a conclusion
Financial ranges so broad they prevent meaningful suitability assessmentRanges specific enough to make concentration and suitability assessments meaningful
Noting only that a client directed a tradeFull suitability analysis documented, including the advisor's recommendation and steps taken, even for client-directed trades

What enforcement shows

CIRO hearing panels have sanctioned both advisors and firms over what was, or was not, in the client file. Three matters decided between 2024 and 2026 show the shape of it across both dealer channels. One caution on how to read them: most of the documentation matters in this window were settlements, which record facts the respondent agreed to rather than findings made on contested evidence. That distinction is noted for each case below.

Supervision of note-taking: Re National Bank Financial, 2026 CIRO 09 (external site, opens in a new tab). In March 2026 a CIRO hearing panel accepted a settlement in which National Bank Financial Inc. (NBF) admitted it had failed to adequately supervise the trading activity of a registered representative with respect to note-taking and suitability between April 2021 and August 2022. The agreed facts record that the April 2021 trade volume report listed 5,887 trades, that NBF asked the representative for the notes behind twelve of them, and that those twelve notes were inadequate. The parties agreed, and the panel adopted as an aggravating factor, that "the inadequacy of the notes reviewed ... should have raised further red flags." A closer review after CIRO opened an investigation found no notes for 49% of the June 2021 trades reviewed and 17% of the July trades reviewed. NBF was fined $1 million with costs of $50,000. The representative's own case was heard separately (Re Ewing, 2025 CIRO 39 (external site, opens in a new tab)). In July 2025 the panel in that case found conduct below professional standards under IDPC Rule 1400 and personal financial dealings with clients, and in January 2026 it imposed a ten-year suspension, a $75,000 fine and $50,000 in costs (external site, opens in a new tab); allegations of falsifying portfolio overview documents and of unauthorized discretionary trading were dismissed. There was no stand-alone note-keeping charge, and that panel said there was "no evidence" that his notes were any less acceptable than those of his peers (Re Ewing, 2025 CIRO 39, para. 133). The settlement with the firm rests on a different point: what the firm saw in the notes it sampled should have led it to insist on notes confirming client instructions, and it did not.

Note content: Re Short, 2025 CIRO 40 (external site, opens in a new tab). A dealing representative with a mutual fund dealer admitted, and the hearing panel confirmed, that he had created notes on the dealer's system on 13 occasions "containing false or misleading information about whether clients had personally signed" account forms. That conduct sat alongside electronically signing 356 account forms for 135 clients and making false or misleading statements to the dealer during its investigation. The panel confirmed a two-year prohibition, a $20,000 fine and $5,000 in costs. This was a settlement, so the facts were agreed rather than adjudicated. What it shows is narrow and useful: the content of a note is regulated conduct in its own right, and the dealer's system is where that content is tested.

Recorded client information: Re Vaarsi, 2024 CIRO 02 (external site, opens in a new tab). As CIRO's decision notice of 17 July 2023 (external site, opens in a new tab) records, the respondent altered 26 account forms for 22 clients between May 2016 and November 2018 without having the clients initial the alterations, contrary to Mutual Fund Dealer Rule 2.1.1. The hearing panel accepted a settlement with a $22,500 fine and $2,500 in costs. This was a settlement, so the facts were agreed and not adjudicated.


The same records work in the other direction

Re White (2024 CIRO 67) (external site, opens in a new tab), decided on 12 August 2024, cuts differently. It was a contested suitability case. It was not a record-keeping case, and no record-keeping contravention was alleged. CIRO Enforcement alleged that an advisor had failed to use due diligence to ensure his recommendations were suitable for three clients between January 2017 and January 2020. He admitted that certain recommendations to two of them, a married couple, were unsuitable, and the hearing panel found against him on those. On the third client, the panel accepted his evidence and found the allegation not proved. The penalty decision (2025 CIRO 04), announced by CIRO on 5 February 2025 (external site, opens in a new tab), imposed a $5,000 fine and $3,000 in disgorgement.

The allegation about the third client turned on credibility, because the advisor and his former client gave very different accounts of what had been discussed and agreed. The panel found that his handwritten notes for 2017 and 2018 corroborated his account. It recorded that the notes had been kept in the dealer's custody until the dealer produced them at CIRO's request, and that he had no opportunity to alter them before they were produced (Re White, 2024 CIRO 67, para. 97). It found that the notes, combined with his oral testimony, tipped the balance strongly in favour of his account (para. 125).

Documentation runs both ways. It is what an examiner tests when a file is reviewed, and it is what an advisor has when a client's memory of a conversation differs from their own. The custody point is worth carrying into any decision about note-taking tools: the notes the panel relied on were ones the advisor had no opportunity to alter before they were produced.


What the enforcement record does not yet say

A search of the CanLII CIRO collection on 4 August 2026, covering all 171 hearing panel decisions from January 2024 to May 2026, found none that addresses AI-generated meeting summaries or third-party note-taking tools, either as an aggravating factor or as an exculpating one. The regulatory infrastructure has moved ahead of the enforcement record. The 2026 Compliance Report says CIRO's Financial and Operations examinations will ask about AI use, and Staff Notice 31-368 expects evidence that a meaningful interaction took place with the client.

For an advisor deciding whether to use an AI tool, the question the file has to answer is the same. Whatever produced the note, the record still has to show what was discussed, what was recommended, and why that recommendation was reasonable for that client.


How long meeting records are kept

Securities law requires a registered firm to keep its required records for seven years from the date the record is created (NI 31-103, s. 11.6(1) (external site, opens in a new tab)). Mutual Fund Dealer Rule 5.6 (external site, opens in a new tab) sets the same period for mutual fund dealers, and IDPC Rule 3800 is the books and records rule for investment dealers. The duty to keep the record sits with the dealer. The advisor's part is to make a record the dealer can keep. The seven years run from the date the record is created, not from the date the client relationship ends.

Seven years means that meeting notes taken today could be requested during a CIRO examination in 2033. If a complaint or enforcement matter arises, those notes become evidence. Re White shows what notes held by the dealer can do: the panel found that they corroborated the advisor's account of one client relationship. If the notes do not exist or cannot be produced, the advisor has no documentary record to support their position.

This is why the format and storage system matters as much as the content. The rules do not prescribe a medium. NI 31-103, s. 11.6(1), requires that a record be kept "in a safe location and in a durable form." Handwritten notes held in the dealer's files can meet that description, and the notes in Re White were handwritten. Notes that stay in an advisor's own drawer are harder to show as safely kept, dated and unaltered. Digital systems with timestamps and version history make those points easier to show.


The connection worth seeing

The five factors CIRO requires documented are the same factors a thorough advisor already considers during a good client meeting.

KYC is understanding the client's full situation. KYP is knowing what you are recommending. Account impact is considering how this fits the broader picture. Cost impact is being transparent about what clients pay. Reasonable alternatives is considering other options before settling on a recommendation.

These are not separate compliance activities. They are professional client service, formalized.

The documentation standard asks advisors to capture what is already happening in their thorough client conversations. For the advisor who is already having comprehensive conversations and making thoughtful recommendations, what remains is mostly recording the reasoning. The practice is already there.


Where AI tools fit in meeting documentation compliance

The five-factor framework creates a documentation standard that is specific enough to evaluate but broad enough that the format is left to the advisor and their firm. CIRO does not prescribe how documentation is produced, only what it must demonstrate.

This is where AI-assisted meeting documentation enters the picture. Tools designed for financial advisor meetings can capture the substance of a conversation and structure it around the documentation elements CIRO requires: what KYC information was discussed, what products were considered, how suitability was assessed, what costs were addressed, and what alternatives were evaluated. The advisor still exercises the professional judgment. The tool handles the recording and structuring.

The regulatory question is whether AI tools can be used for this purpose at all. The 2026 Compliance Report says AI use in dealers' operations is part of CIRO's Financial and Operations examination approach, and that where dealers use AI, CIRO will review the operational controls they implemented. As at 13 November 2026, CIRO has published no rule or guidance note specific to AI. The full compliance analysis of whether CIRO allows AI meeting notes covers the regulatory landscape in detail.

For advisors evaluating specific tools, the compliance considerations differ depending on whether client data leaves the advisor's device and where it is processed. The analyses of ChatGPT and Claude from a Canadian compliance perspective cover these distinctions.

The underlying point is simpler than the technology discussion suggests. The documentation standard exists. Contemporaneous notes carry evidentiary weight. The five factors are specific. Whether an advisor captures them by hand, through a CRM, or with the assistance of an AI tool, the standard remains the same.


Where do your notes stand?

Pull up your last three meeting notes. Not the best ones. The most recent three.

If three or four of those are covered in the notes, moving from current practice to what CIRO considers examination-ready is likely a matter of specificity and consistency. The practice itself is already there.

If you want a structured way to evaluate your documentation against the five-factor standard, the Documentation Standards Kit sets out what a Canadian client meeting record needs to contain, with the regulatory basis for each block. It is written to be read against whatever template you already use: where your existing record already carries the required content, the block is satisfied. Where an AI tool is part of how the record gets made, the free Compliance Conversation Kit covers the approval conversation with your compliance team.


Frequently asked questions

What does CIRO look for in meeting documentation?

CIRO expects documentation that demonstrates a reasonable basis for each suitability determination, addressing five factors: client KYC information, KYP assessment, account impact, cost impact, and consideration of reasonable alternatives. These requirements are codified under the Client Focused Reforms in IDPC Rule 3402(1) and NI 31-103 s. 13.3(1).

Does CIRO require notes for every client meeting?

CIRO's record-keeping rules are addressed to the dealer, and no rule prescribes notes for every meeting. However, the obligation to demonstrate compliance through documentation creates a practical expectation that significant client interactions are documented. In Re White, 2024 CIRO 67, a CIRO hearing panel found that an advisor's handwritten notes corroborated his account of a client relationship.

How long are meeting documentation records kept?

A dealer keeps its required records for seven years from the date the record is created (NI 31-103, s. 11.6(1) (external site, opens in a new tab); Mutual Fund Dealer Rule 5.6 (external site, opens in a new tab)). IDPC Rule 3800 is the books and records rule for investment dealers. Records must be stored in a manner that allows them to be produced upon request during a CIRO examination. Systems with audit trails or timestamps strengthen the evidentiary value of the records.

How quickly do meeting notes need to be completed?

CIRO does not prescribe a specific documentation timeline. No "same day" or "24-hour" rule exists. Notes made at the time and held in the dealer's custody are the kind a hearing panel has relied on as corroboration (Re White, 2024 CIRO 67). This is good practice drawn from one decision, not a binding timeframe.

What is the difference between a CIRO examination and an audit?

CIRO conducts "examinations," not "audits." An audit verifies financial statements; a CIRO examination assesses regulatory compliance. CIRO's Business Conduct Compliance (BCC) group is the one whose staff are named on Staff Notice 31-368, the review of KYC, KYP and suitability practices.


Key regulatory references

SourceTypeWhat it covers
IDPC Rule 3402(1)Binding ruleFive-factor suitability determination; reasonable basis standard
NI 31-103 s. 13.3(1)Securities lawSuitability including client-first obligation
IDPC Rule 3202(1)(iii)Binding ruleKYC information collection, including the client's risk profile
IDPC Rules 3300/3302Binding ruleKYP assessment and product understanding
IDPC Rule 3800Binding ruleBooks and records for investment dealers
NI 31-103 s. 11.6(1) (external site, opens in a new tab)Securities lawRecords kept by the registered firm for 7 years from the date the record is created
Joint CSA/CIRO Staff Notice 31-368 (10 December 2025) (external site, opens in a new tab)Regulatory guidanceIssues identified and guidance from compliance reviews of 105 registered firms
GN-3400-21-004 (external site, opens in a new tab)CIRO guidanceKnow-your-client and suitability determination for retail clients
Re White, 2024 CIRO 67 (external site, opens in a new tab)Hearing panel decisionHandwritten notes as corroboration of an advisor's account
CIRO's Compliance Report for 2026 (external site, opens in a new tab) (Administrative Bulletin 26-0034, released 17 February 2026)Regulatory signalSays of Staff Notice 31-368: "BCC examinations will focus on assessing whether dealers have taken steps to rectify any deficiencies identified in the report that may be applicable to their firm."
Rule Consolidation Project (Rules Bulletin 26-0039 (external site, opens in a new tab), 12 February 2026)Proposed rulesOne set of CIRO Rules to replace the IDPC Rules and the Mutual Fund Dealer Rules; comment period closed 12 June 2026

The standard is navigable

The five-factor framework is specific. The examples in Staff Notice 31-368 are concrete. The proportionality principle acknowledges that context matters. And the practices required for good documentation map closely to the practices of good client service.

The question that remains is personal. Not whether the standard is clear. It is. But whether your documentation currently captures the professional judgment you are already exercising when you sit across from a client and do the work you were trained to do.

That conversation with your compliance officer is worth having. Not from avoidance. From understanding.

At the end of the path

Documentation Standards Kit

The content standard a meeting record is measured against.

Written by

Sandra Lyne

Founder, Northern Catalyst

TagsCIROComplianceFinancial AdvisorsMeeting DocumentationCanada

This is educational content based on published regulatory sources as at the page's last-updated date. It is not legal, compliance, or financial advice. Review specific compliance decisions with your compliance officer and qualified legal counsel before implementation.

Source: Joint CSA/CIRO Staff Notice 31-368 · 10 December 2025

Re-verified