Skip to content

Territory 5 · AI governance

Why do Canadian advisors need different AI guidance?

US AI compliance guidance from FINRA and Kitces does not address Canadian requirements. Five material differences between the US and Canadian frameworks.

Updated 3 min read
An instrument maker’s hands setting a small offset on a brass dial.

Why Canadian Advisors Need Canadian-Specific Guidance

1.1 The US Framework Canadian Advisors Inherit

The most widely read AI compliance content in financial services is American. Michael Kitces covers SEC requirements. FINRA's Regulatory Notice 24-09 (June 2024) addresses US broker-dealer obligations. The FPA launched FPAi Authority in January 2026 for US financial planners. Canadian advisors read this content because it is the most accessible and frequently updated material available.

The problem is not that US guidance is wrong. The problem is that it is incomplete for Canadian advisors. The regulatory frameworks are materially different.

1.2 Five ways US guidance differs for Canadian advisors

DimensionUS ApproachCanadian ApproachWhy It Matters
Privacy consent modelOpt-out (consumer must refuse)Opt-in for sensitive data (express consent required)US guidance never addresses Canadian consent requirements
Federal privacy lawNo comprehensive equivalentPIPEDA (applies to all provinces for cross-border)Different baseline obligations
Provincial privacyState-by-state patchworkQuebec Law 25 reaches across provincial bordersNo US equivalent to cross-provincial reach
Industry AI guidanceFINRA 24-09 (prescriptive, June 2024)CSA 11-348 (principles-based, December 2024)Different regulatory frameworks, different obligations
Cross-border dataNo comparable federal requirementPIPEDA accountability travels with data; Law 25 mandates PIAUS tools ignore these requirements

FINRA Regulatory Notice 24-09 and CSA Staff Notice 11-348 were published six months apart. They share a topic. They share almost nothing else. FINRA is prescriptive: specific rules for specific situations. The CSA is principles-based: existing securities laws apply to the activity, not the technology.

1.3 Canadian guidance so far

As at 13 November 2026, guidance written for Canadian advisors is beginning to appear. The FP Canada Standards Council published "Responsible Use of Generative Artificial Intelligence: Guidance for the Profession" (external site, opens in a new tab) as a staff bulletin in February 2026, for CFP and QAFP professionals. The Investment Industry Association of Canada, now the Canadian Forum for Financial Markets (external site, opens in a new tab), responded to the CSA's consultation (external site, opens in a new tab) on Staff Notice 11-348 on 31 March 2025.

At the end of the path

Compliance Conversation Kit

Free. The material for the conversation with the compliance officer.

This is educational content based on published regulatory sources as at the page's last-updated date. It is not legal, compliance, or financial advice. Review specific compliance decisions with your compliance officer and qualified legal counsel before implementation.

Source: Joint CSA/CIRO Staff Notice 31-368 · 10 December 2025

Re-verified