Skip to content

Territory 1 · The meeting record

Client Focused Reforms Documentation: An Advisor Guide

The four documentation pillars Canadian advisors need to capture under the Client Focused Reforms, what regulators keep finding, and what AI tools must do.

Updated 10 min readSandra Lyne
A mechanical watch movement seen through its open case back, the balance wheel caught mid-swing, one jewel catching the light.

Joint CSA/CIRO Staff Notice 31-368 (10 December 2025) (external site, opens in a new tab) reports compliance reviews of 105 registered firms under the Client Focused Reforms, which have been fully in effect since 31 December 2021. The Notice does not say how many of the 105 firms were affected. It lists the issues staff identified across KYC, KYP, suitability determination, and policies and procedures, and sets out what staff expect.

Much of what the Notice describes sits in the step between the conversation and the record. Advisors talk about costs, weigh alternatives, and make suitability judgments in client meetings every week. Then the discussion about cost impact becomes "discussed costs." The alternatives actually considered become "alternatives were appropriate." Months later, in a compliance review, the file shows the action but not the reasoning.

Read alongside how documentation happens in an advisor's week, the pattern is clearer than the regulatory text makes it look.

What regulators keep finding in the record

The same themes run through three publications. CIRO's Compliance Report for 2025 (Administrative Bulletin 25-0035, released 31 January 2025) (external site, opens in a new tab) gave early results of the second phase of Client Focused Reforms reviews. Staff Notice 31-368 set them out in full. CIRO's Compliance Report for 2026 (Administrative Bulletin 26-0034, released 17 February 2026) (external site, opens in a new tab) returned to them. Among the issues the Notice identifies: financial information collected in ranges too wide to support a suitability determination; issuer documents kept on file with no record of how they were reviewed; suitability records that do not show the basis for the determination; and policies and procedures that repeat the rule requirements without saying how the firm complies.

The rule-by-rule architecture is in What CIRO Requires in Meeting Documentation. This page picks up where that one ends, with Northern Catalyst's own observation: the underlying work is mostly happening. What remains is the record.

A suitability determination rests on five factors under IDPC Rule 3402(1)(i) and MFD Rule 2.2.6(1)(a), and the action must also put the client's interest first. Most advisors weigh all five during a client meeting and few capture all five afterwards in the file. The 2025 Compliance Report names one pattern directly. In its review of client accounts, CIRO "observed instances where KYC information should have been queried for reasonability, but it was not." A question asked in the meeting shows in a review only when the file records it.

What two enforcement cases show

In March 2026 a CIRO hearing panel accepted a settlement with National Bank Financial Inc. (Re National Bank Financial, 2026 CIRO 09 (external site, opens in a new tab)). The firm admitted that it had failed to adequately supervise a registered representative's trading activity with respect to note-taking and suitability, and agreed to a $1 million fine and $50,000 in costs. The agreed facts record that the firm had sampled his notes, found the sample inadequate, and did not then insist on notes confirming client instructions.

In August 2024, in Re White, 2024 CIRO 67 (external site, opens in a new tab), a CIRO hearing panel decided a suitability case that turned on whose account of the client relationships to accept. The advisor admitted that certain recommendations to two clients were unsuitable, and the panel found against him on those. On the third client it accepted his account. His handwritten notes for 2017 and 2018 had been kept in his dealer's custody until the dealer produced them at CIRO's request, and the panel recorded that he had no opportunity to alter them before they were produced (para. 97). It found that the notes corroborated his account and that, combined with his oral testimony, they tipped the balance strongly in his favour (para. 125). No record-keeping contravention was alleged.

The two cases sit on either side of the same observation. Across regulatory reviews, complaint hearings, and supervisory examinations, documentation is the artifact that survives. When it is captured in real time, in a form that is preserved without depending on the advisor's later recollection, it can corroborate one account of events over another. The rules are specific about what has to be in those records.

A supervision settlement

CIRO SETTLEMENT · MARCH 2026

National Bank Financial Inc. agreed to a $1 million fine and $50,000 in costs after admitting it had failed to adequately supervise a registered representative's trading activity with respect to note-taking and suitability. The firm had sampled his notes, found the sample inadequate, and did not adequately investigate the red flags.

When notes were the credible record

HEARING PANEL DECISION · 2024

Re White, 2024 CIRO 67. Handwritten notes, held in the dealer's custody until the dealer produced them to CIRO, corroborated the advisor's account of one client relationship. On two other clients the panel found against him, on his own admission.

What a Client Focused Reforms meeting record has to show

Client Focused Reforms documentation rests on four pillars: KYC information, KYP assessment, suitability determination, and alternatives considered. Each has rule citations and a body of guidance behind it; What CIRO Requires walks the architecture rule-by-rule.

PillarWhat it capturesWhere it is specified
KYC informationThe client's personal and financial circumstances, investment needs and objectives, investment knowledge, risk profile, and investment time horizon. Guidance since the reforms describes the risk profile as two parts, risk tolerance and risk capacity.IDPC Rule 3202, NI 31-103 s.13.2, MFD Rule 2.2.1
KYP assessmentThe registrant's own analysis of the product, not the issuer's documentation filed without reviewIDPC Rule 3300, MFD Rule 2.2.5, NI 31-103 s.13.2.1
Suitability determinationThe five factors: KYC, KYP, account impact, cost impact, and a reasonable range of alternativesIDPC Rule 3402(1)(i), MFD Rule 2.2.6(1), NI 31-103 s.13.3(1)(a)
Alternatives consideredThe specific alternatives weighed and why the recommendation was chosen over themSame as suitability; flagged in Staff Notice 31-368 as commonly missing

What AI meeting documentation has to do

A tool that helps with Client Focused Reforms documentation has to do specific work in each of the four pillar areas. KYC updates from the conversation need to land in language a supervisor can read months later. KYP rationale belongs on the page. The suitability discussion has to show cost, concentration, and alternatives. The alternatives considered, and why they were not chosen, have to be in the file.

CSA Staff Notice and Consultation 11-348 (5 December 2024) (external site, opens in a new tab) sets out staff's expectations for AI in advisor workflows. For KYC and onboarding, registrants can consider using AI systems "provided an appropriate degree of explainability is available so that a human can monitor for and correct any errors in a timely manner." For client accounts, "using an AI system directly in suitability determinations and trading decisions will be problematic unless a high degree of explainability is assured." The advisor remains the registered representative responsible for the recommendation. The AI output is an input to the file. The advisor reviews it, accepts or revises it, and signs off. AI produces a draft. The advisor's judgment decides what the record says.

A high degree of explainability.

CSA Staff Notice and Consultation 11-348 (5 December 2024), on AI used directly in suitability determinations and trading decisions for client accounts. For KYC and onboarding the Notice speaks of 'an appropriate degree'.

PIPEDA and Quebec Law 25 add a second layer. Before a transcript reaches any third-party service, the advisor and the firm need to know what personal information it carries, where it is processed, and under what agreement. Tools answer this in different ways: some remove identifying details on the advisor's device before anything is sent, and others keep processing inside systems the firm already governs. Either way the answer belongs in the file.

Whatever produces the draft, the record is read against the same standard. The Documentation Standards Kit sets out what a Canadian client meeting record needs to contain, with the regulatory basis for each block.

What your compliance department will want to verify

A compliance review of AI meeting documentation walks six checkpoints: material business change notification, outsourcing obligations, vendor sampling and verification, KYC explainability, suitability explainability, and PIPEDA and Quebec Law 25 obligations.

For firm counsel. Six checkpoints, in the order a compliance review walks through them.

  1. Material business change notification. The 2026 Compliance Report says dealers "should also assess whether any use of AI and/or automation of its regulatory functions is a material business change", and points to Guidance Note GN-2200-21-001 (external site, opens in a new tab), Reporting of material changes to business activities. The Report also says: "To the extent dealers are using AI, we will be reviewing the operational controls they implemented to ensure AI is working as designed." On the Client Focused Reforms, the same Report says policies and procedures that "simply reiterate the principles-based rules" without detail on the firm's own processes "are inadequate."

  2. Outsourcing. A third-party AI tool that performs a function for an investment dealer comes within CIRO's Guidance Note GN-2300-21-003 (external site, opens in a new tab), Outsourcing arrangements. The dealer "retains the responsibility to ensure" that the outsourced activity meets CIRO's rules and securities legislation. Assessing the vendor at the start and supervising it afterwards sit with the firm.

  3. Vendor sampling and verification. Staff Notice 11-348 says that supervising an outsourced service provider "will require registrants in some cases to review and verify samples of processes that use AI systems." The expectation lasts for as long as the firm uses the tool.

  4. KYC explainability. Staff Notice 11-348 expects "an appropriate degree of explainability" where AI is used in KYC and onboarding, so that a human can monitor for and correct errors.

  5. Suitability explainability. Of AI used directly in suitability determinations for client accounts, Staff Notice 11-348 says the use "will be problematic unless a high degree of explainability is assured."

  6. PIPEDA and Quebec Law 25. If client data is transmitted to a third-party AI service, the firm is responsible for ensuring appropriate safeguards. Quebec Law 25 (external site, opens in a new tab) adds its own rules on consent, on notifying the Commission d'accès à l'information and the people concerned of a confidentiality incident that presents a risk of serious injury, and on communicating personal information outside Quebec. Personal information routed to AI infrastructure outside Quebec, in another province or another country, falls within those rules.

At the end of the path

Documentation Standards Kit

The content standard a meeting record is measured against.

Written by

Sandra Lyne

Founder, Northern Catalyst

TagsClient Focused ReformsCIRODocumentationAI meeting documentationCanadian Financial Advisors

This is educational content based on published regulatory sources as at the page's last-updated date. It is not legal, compliance, or financial advice. Review specific compliance decisions with your compliance officer and qualified legal counsel before implementation.

Source: Joint CSA/CIRO Staff Notice 31-368 · 10 December 2025

Re-verified