Skip to content

Territory 5 · AI governance

What Shadow AI Looks Like in a Canadian Advisory Practice

What shadow AI looks like in a Canadian advisory practice. The tools, the workflows, and what CIRO, PIPEDA, and Law 25 mean when it touches client data.

Updated 12 min readSandra Lyne
An instrument maker’s hands setting a small offset on a brass dial.

Few Canadian advisors were describing their own AI use in public while CIRO moved from one sentence on artificial intelligence in its Compliance Report for 2025 (external site, opens in a new tab) to a section on AI in its Compliance Report for 2026 (external site, opens in a new tab) (Administrative Bulletin 26-0034, released 17 February 2026). That section makes AI part of CIRO's Financial and Operations (FinOps) examination approach.

What shadow AI looks like inside a Canadian advisory practice

Shadow AI in a Canadian advisory practice means consumer AI tools used for client work without dealer approval. Personal ChatGPT open on a firm laptop. Otter joining a Zoom before compliance has seen the vendor. A Copilot prompt running through a home Microsoft 365 subscription. An IBM study (external site, opens in a new tab) released on 3 September 2025, fielded in May 2025, found 79% of Canadian full-time office workers using AI at work, with only 25% relying on enterprise-grade tools. The survey sampled office workers who were familiar with AI tools, and it does not break its figures out by profession, so it gives no rate for advisors.

The shape of the workflow matters more than the headline rate. An advisor described a pattern among the advisors he works with: most do not have defined processes for how meetings get documented, how follow-up gets tracked, or how client-facing drafts get reviewed before they go out. Practice management is built meeting by meeting, assembled rather than designed. When a new AI tool arrives, it drops onto unstructured ground. The tool produces output. The advisor still has to turn that output into something usable, and the cleaning often takes longer than the time saved in generating it.

The advisor who reaches for a consumer AI tool is often running ten or twelve hour days with little support. ChatGPT or Claude is the nearest help to hand. What would help more is a defined process, and that is something a consumer tool cannot supply on its own.

Why personal ChatGPT replaces firm software when the process is undefined

Three tasks show up most often in the substitution pattern: meeting transcription where there is no agreed template, client email drafting where there is no style standard, and KYC narrative writing where the narrative is rebuilt from scratch every time. ChatGPT and Claude step in where the workflow was never defined. Copilot sits in a different category at a dealer that has approved it as part of a Microsoft 365 environment, where it uses the sanctioned rail rather than a personal account. Northern Catalyst's Advisor Copilot Toolkit is built for that route: agents that run inside the firm's own Microsoft 365 tenant.

The cleanup is where the cost appears. An AI meeting tool produces a transcript, a summary, and a set of action items. The advisor then has to decide which of those summary points is useful, which action items are real, which wording is fit for a compliance file, and which details the tool hallucinated or misattributed. The output is raw material, not a finished document. The advisor who does not have a documentation standard to check it against spends the saved time on cleanup, and the time saved evaporates into the time spent cleaning up.

Why dealers have not approved the tools advisors want

The permission architecture at a Canadian dealer is built for system attachment, not cognitive use. When a vendor arrives with a tool that will integrate with the firm's CRM, calendar, or email, five roles take a look before the tool is approved: Chief Compliance Officer, Legal, Information Security, Privacy, and Senior Management. The gate clicks at integration, not at use.

This is the reason the advisor with a personal Claude account on a firm laptop is invisible to the process, and the Zocks or Focal AI vendor attempting to attach to the same firm's CRM is not. Same advisor, same intention to document meetings better, two entirely different paths through the dealer's oversight architecture. One path is private and immediate. The other is public, sequenced, and long.

Permission is named as the gate. Integration is named as the point where the gate clicks.

Advisor.ca's review of AI notetaking apps (external site, opens in a new tab) (20 March 2025) reported one advisor's caution that users "should check with their firm to ensure they have permission" before integrating an app with their CRM and calendar software. That sentence carries the architecture on its own. Permission is named as the gate, and integration is named as the point where the gate clicks.

The pattern inside firms where AI tools have been mandated rather than chosen runs differently again. Advisors tend to adopt the tools they choose, and a tool mandated without their input can sit unused. A dealer that tries to solve the shadow AI question by pushing an approved tool into advisor workflows without advisor input tends to find the tool fitting badly with how advisors actually work. The compliance logs fill up, and the advisor's real work continues in the tools that match the shape of the meeting and the client relationship.

What four Canadian regulators say when shadow AI meets client data

Four regimes converge when a Canadian advisor's AI use touches client information.

RegulatorInstrumentWhat it says where AI touches client data
CIROCompliance Report for 2026 (external site, opens in a new tab) (Administrative Bulletin 26-0034, released 17 February 2026)AI use in dealers' operations is part of CIRO's FinOps examination approach. Where dealers use AI, CIRO will review the operational controls they implemented.
CSACSA Staff Notice and Consultation 11-348 (external site, opens in a new tab) (5 December 2024)Sets out how existing securities law applies when registrants and other market participants use AI systems. It is staff guidance, and it says market participants are responsible for the outputs of the technology they use, including AI systems.
OPC (federal)PIPEDA, Principle 4.1.3 (external site, opens in a new tab)An organization remains responsible for personal information it transfers to a third party for processing, and must use contractual or other means to provide a comparable level of protection while the third party processes it. The principle does not name AI; it applies whenever a third party processes the information.
Quebec CAILaw 25, sections 3.3 and 17 (external site, opens in a new tab)A privacy impact assessment is required for any project to acquire, develop or overhaul an information system that involves personal information, and before personal information is communicated outside Quebec.

CIRO named the shift in plain language. The 2026 Compliance Report (external site, opens in a new tab) says: "As part of our FinOps examination approach, we will be enquiring about the use of AI in dealers' operations. To the extent dealers are using AI, we will be reviewing the operational controls they implemented to ensure AI is working as designed." Two sentences, both inquiry verbs, both operational.

CIRO chose supervision over rulebook. The 2026 Compliance Report does not publish model risk management standards, explainability requirements, or AI inventory mandates. It relies on existing rules plus examination authority. What counts as acceptable AI use will be decided at the examination interface, not in a rule consultation. Compliance officers reading the report will recognize the architecture immediately: the regulator has named AI as a topic of inquiry without narrowing in advance what acceptable AI looks like. That leaves the dealer to define acceptable use, and the advisor's part is to keep a record of actual use.

Staff of the CSA and CIRO reviewed 105 registered firms and published the results, with guidance, in Joint CSA/CIRO Staff Notice 31-368 (external site, opens in a new tab) on 10 December 2025. The Notice is about the Client Focused Reforms, and it does not count the firms affected. It observed that in some cases, firms' policies and procedures "simply repeated the rule requirements without any detail regarding how compliance is to be achieved at the specific firm and what level of documentation is required to provide evidence of compliance." Documentation. Evidence of compliance. What the regulators are asking for is documentation.

Two handholds follow. An advisor serving any Quebec client needs to confirm whether a privacy impact assessment under Law 25 exists for the tool in use. An advisor at an investment dealer can ask whether the firm has assessed its AI use as a possible material business change. The 2026 Compliance Report (external site, opens in a new tab) says dealers "should also assess whether any use of AI and/or automation of its regulatory functions is a material business change", which would call for advance written notice to CIRO, a Form 33-109F5 (Change of Registration Information) filing, or both. Guidance Note GN-2200-21-001 (external site, opens in a new tab) gives the detail. Two questions, jurisdiction-matched.

What sanctioned firm AI governance looks like in practice

Sanctioned firm AI governance, in practice, comes down to four moving parts. Two signals point in the same direction. CIRO has moved AI from mention to examination. In Advisor.ca's review of AI notetaking apps (external site, opens in a new tab) (20 March 2025), advisors gave specific grounds for choosing a tool.

The advisors who contributed to that review weighed different things. The review advises Canadian advisors to look for tools that recognize Canadian terms such as RRSP and TFSA, and notes that those with francophone clients may want French-language support. One advisor said he was willing to pay a premium for an app with strong security safeguards. Another raised the permission point quoted above: check with the firm first, then integrate.

Across those criteria the same pattern repeats: a stated reason for choosing a tool, and a permission conversation with the firm where one applies. Northern Catalyst adds two more parts: a documented evaluation decision, and a documentation practice underneath the tool that the advisor can point to when a compliance officer asks.

Two questions to ask first

Two questions take an advisor from current practice to a defensible position, wherever they stand today.

For firms serving one or more Quebec clients. Confirm whether a privacy impact assessment under Law 25 (external site, opens in a new tab) exists for the AI tool currently in use or being considered. If the answer is no, that is the first document to build.

For investment dealers. Confirm whether the firm has assessed its AI use as a possible material business change, using Guidance Note GN-2200-21-001 (external site, opens in a new tab). If it is one, confirm whether the firm has given CIRO advance written notice, filed a Form 33-109F5 (Change of Registration Information), or both. If the answer is no at either step, that is the first conversation to have.

Frequently asked questions

What does Quebec Law 25 require for AI tools handling client data?

An advisor serving any Quebec client needs to confirm whether a privacy impact assessment under Law 25 exists for the AI tool in use. Law 25 (external site, opens in a new tab) requires a privacy impact assessment for any project to acquire, develop or overhaul an information system that involves personal information (section 3.3), scaled to the sensitivity and quantity of the information. Section 17 requires a privacy impact assessment before personal information is communicated outside Quebec. The Act draws the line at Quebec's border, not Canada's, so it reads as covering a transfer to another province as well as to another country. If no assessment exists, that is the first document to build.

Is AI adoption a material business change under CIRO?

As at 13 November 2026, CIRO has set no bright line for when adopting an AI tool is a material business change. Its Guidance Note GN-2200-21-001 (external site, opens in a new tab) says that what is a material change "will depend on the facts and circumstances of each case." The 2026 Compliance Report (external site, opens in a new tab) says dealers "should also assess whether any use of AI and/or automation of its regulatory functions is a material business change", which would call for advance written notice to CIRO, a Form 33-109F5 (Change of Registration Information) filing, or both. An advisor at an investment dealer can ask whether the firm has assessed its AI use as a possible material business change.

At the end of the path

Compliance Conversation Kit

Free. The material for the conversation with the compliance officer.

Written by

Sandra Lyne

Founder, Northern Catalyst

TagsShadow AICIROCanadian Financial AdvisorsAI GovernanceCompliance

This is educational content based on published regulatory sources as at the page's last-updated date. It is not legal, compliance, or financial advice. Review specific compliance decisions with your compliance officer and qualified legal counsel before implementation.

Source: Joint CSA/CIRO Staff Notice 31-368 · 10 December 2025

Re-verified